What does it mean and
how does it affect my practice?
Teaching is designing and there is both a science and an
art to the profession. To begin, a
teacher needs to have three kinds of knowledge: content knowledge, pedagogical
knowledge, and technological knowledge and these are thought processes used “in
reflection to action”. Then there is
classroom practice which entails planning, delivering instruction and
assessment, evaluation and perhaps, re-teaching. These practices are what we do “in action”. Lastly, there is design knowledge or “design
practice” which is what teachers do “before action”. This instructional design practice is what
bridges the previously mentioned teacher knowledge and classroom practice. Educators
need to know the following to be designers: “Teachers need to learn to identify
the ‘real’ design problems. Teachers need to learn to consider and invent
possibilities as well as recognize and embrace constraints. Teachers need to
understand and integrate the four design P’s- principles, processes, patterns,
and paraphernalia.”
To me, design is an informed, strategic approach to
instruction often called the backwards design model. It can be large in scope and challenges
teachers to begin with the end in mind.
This means that teachers first identify desired results- learning goals
or standards. A teacher comes up with an
authentic problem to solve- essential questions to answer. Additionally, an acceptable evidence of
learning is determined- the finished product with a rubric or other instrument to
measure student success. After this, the
teacher or team of teachers design learning experiences and instruction using
best practices. When it comes to best
practices, I remember these three questions that I learned in a college course
in the 90’s, and still find them so important to use as a guide in my practice
when designing instruction: Is it knowable to the learner?, Is it meaningful to
the learner? Is it purposeful to the learner?
Best practices also encompass the practice of actively engaging
students, developing critical thinking in students, giving them ample time to
practice while the teacher guides them, fostering the ability to question and
nurturing the desire to wonder, allowing time for reflection on learning, and providing
opportunity for students to give and receive feedback, just to name a few.
As a librarian, this impacts my practice of being a
resource to the staff at all grade levels that I work with in my building. As the county continues to implement its One
to the World initiative and expect teachers to embrace project-based learning
and B-Y-O-T, Bring Your Own Technology, my role is morphing into a media
specialist/technology resource teacher.
It is becoming more collaborative in nature and the county is moving in
the direction of utilizing a flexible schedule in the library at the elementary
level where grade level 3-5 teachers would bring their class to the library
with a set purpose/need that is planned collaboratively. Time to collaborate is
a constant obstacle as my schedule is fixed and set up/viewed by administration
and teachers alike as a special where teachers drop their kids off so they may
have daily planning time and meet in PLT’s once a week during the school day.
This creates dis-connect between what I want to do with teachers
collaboratively, design instruction, and what I am able to actually do. To compound this challenge is the fact that
the schedule only allows me to work with grades 2-5 classes every other week
which is not conducive to project-based learning. I strive to keep informed of grade level
projects, attend planning meetings as frequently as I can to allow for more
collaboration, and design my lessons to support the context of their project,
learning outcomes, standards, and skills needed by the students. I also assist teachers with their use of
design paraphernalia, technology, as I am facilitating the digital citizenship
curriculum through Common Sense Media to support B-Y-O-T. One area that I am successful is in creating
lessons to support students with sustained inquiry- with their process of
asking questions, finding resources, and applying information. In addition to this, I will be facilitating “Tech
Tuesdays” this year as a way to support the teachers with their integration of
technology into their classroom practice.
One of the One to the World key elements is “Connected with The World”
and when appropriate, students use technology to make these connections with
the world. Another key element is “Public
Product for the World” where students make their work public by displaying
and/or presenting it to people beyond the classroom. Technology and social
media are valuable platforms to support this requirement.
Hi Kim! This is a very thorough and thoughtful blog post. You reminded me of the many of the important things we learned in class. One that I need to be more mindful of is the idea of "embracing the constraints". Right now, a constraint I have is the size of my classroom. Because I work in a private school, the classroom is oddly shaped and not really meant for a music setting... but it's working for now... definitely not something I would have designed had I been given the opportunity. I also appreciate your honesty in sharing the challenges of finding planning time with the teachers. I would love to hear more about Technology Tuesdays.
ReplyDeleteHey Kim! I love that these blogs open my eyes to lots of other teaching and career perspectives. I am an elementary band teacher, so I thought I would be the odd one out with a group of classroom teachers. Glad that's not the case!
ReplyDeleteI LOVE your definition of design - "an informed, strategic approach to instruction often called the backwards design model." In my classes, our end goal is always a concert. I select the music that we'll play, and then figure out which time/key signatures, styles, historical periods, and famous musicians to focus our classes on. It would be crazy stressful for me to wait until the end to figure out what the students need to know.
I commend you on your effort to keep up with what each class in each grade is doing - you are one of the most valuable resources for teachers and students, so I feel like it would be a waste to not keep you in the loop! Schools should be hugely collaborative communities, so why not take advantage of helping each other out? It makes everyone's jobs easier.
Thank you for your words of encouragement. I look forward to learning more about you through your blog.
DeleteHey Kim! Welcome to DooDLeS!
ReplyDeleteIt's so great to meet librarians who fully understand the needs (and struggles) of teachers trying to provide the most rigorous learning environment for their kids. As an English teacher, librarians have, throughout my career, been a critical part of my success. In fact, when I got my first post at Schweinfurt American HS in Germany, one of the first things I did there was go speak with the librarian. Teachers can't possible help students become global citizens without thoughtfully incorporating technology, and at many schools, librarians are often the gatekeepers to this technology. Thanks for all you do!
Zach, thank you for your kind words. I feel my position as a resource teacher/specialist does make it especially challenging to be a designer. Without a flexible schedule, and only seeing many classes every other week does not allow the frequency to support sustainable and well-designed learning. Then, not being able to attend regular and weekly planning with teams of teachers as part of the regular schedule in my building makes it extra challenging to team-teach and help teachers or teams design their learning outcomes. I want the students to truly see the importance and practical application of their learning within the context of what they are doing in the classroom.
DeleteHello Kim. I am only in my second year of being in the classroom. In the past four years I have transitioned from being a graphic designer to now being the technology teacher at a special ed school. Along my journey I read somewhere that it's good to have a teaching philosophy, while I've tried to adopt this thinking, being such a "young" teacher it's hard finding a concrete example as I develop mine. Therefore I really appreciate you sharing what you learned in that college class, "Is it knowable to the learner?, Is it meaningful to the learner? Is it purposeful to the learner?" Three questions I will definitely carry with me too.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your sentiment that more can be done in regards to collaboration among all staff.